At first I was thinking more recency bias…but as I read the recap, I vaguely remember watching this game, and actually being pretty impressed by it. This was well past the time of Tom Brady ascending from the incredible story of a sixth round pick winning a Super Bowl to an annoying Super Bowl fixture, and around the time that everyone legitimately started to think that Peyton Manning (and Tony Dungy) might never live up to their ultimate expectations–in large part due to Brady. Either way, I was going to cheer for the winner of this one against the overrated Bears–but getting to see Manning finally have a chance at a Super Bowl (before HE ascended to overexposed advertising icon) was definitely a classic…although I’m still not 100% sure it belongs in the top 25.
No, another game that happened long after the book was published.
The 2006 AFC Championship Game: Colts vs. Patriots – A Legendary Clash
The 2006 AFC Championship Game between the Indianapolis Colts and the New England Patriots is remembered as one of the greatest games in NFL history. Played on January 21, 2007, at the RCA Dome in Indianapolis, this game featured a dramatic comeback, legendary performances, and a thrilling finish that secured its place among the top 25 NFL games of all time. The Colts’ remarkable rally from an 18-point deficit to a 38-34 victory over the Patriots showcased the resilience and determination of one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history, Peyton Manning.
Pre-Game Context
The Indianapolis Colts, led by head coach Tony Dungy and quarterback Peyton Manning, finished the regular season with a 12-4 record. The Colts were known for their high-powered offense, featuring wide receivers Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne, and running back Joseph Addai. Despite their regular-season success, the Colts had struggled in previous playoff matchups against their perennial rivals, the New England Patriots.
The Patriots, under head coach Bill Belichick and quarterback Tom Brady, were seeking their fourth Super Bowl appearance in six years. With a 12-4 regular-season record, the Patriots were known for their disciplined defense, clutch performances, and the leadership of Brady. This matchup was highly anticipated, pitting two of the league’s best quarterbacks against each other with a trip to Super Bowl XLI on the line.
The First Half: Patriots Dominate Early
The game began with the Patriots taking control early, capitalizing on Colts’ mistakes and showcasing their defensive prowess. New England’s Asante Samuel intercepted a pass from Manning and returned it 39 yards for a touchdown, giving the Patriots a 21-3 lead. The Colts managed to score a field goal, but the Patriots responded with another touchdown, extending their lead to 21-6 at halftime.
Indianapolis’ offense struggled to find rhythm, and their usually stout defense had difficulty containing Brady and the Patriots’ attack. The first half ended with the Colts facing an 18-point deficit, and their Super Bowl dreams appeared to be slipping away.
The Second Half: Colts Begin to Rally
The second half saw a dramatic shift in momentum. The Colts came out with renewed energy and determination. Manning led a touchdown drive, capped by a 1-yard run by Dan Klecko, and followed by a successful two-point conversion pass to Marvin Harrison, cutting the Patriots’ lead to 21-14.
The Colts’ defense then made a crucial stop, and Manning orchestrated another scoring drive, culminating in a 1-yard touchdown run by center Jeff Saturday, who recovered a fumble in the end zone. The game was now tied at 21-21, and the RCA Dome was electrified with the possibility of an epic comeback.
The Fourth Quarter: A Battle to the Finish
The fourth quarter was a back-and-forth battle, with both teams trading scores in a dramatic showdown:
Patriots Strike Back: Brady connected with Jabar Gaffney for a 6-yard touchdown pass, giving the Patriots a 28-21 lead.
Colts Respond: Manning led another drive, resulting in a 12-yard touchdown pass to Reggie Wayne. However, the extra point was blocked, leaving the Colts trailing 28-27.
Patriots Extend the Lead: The Patriots added two field goals, increasing their lead to 34-31.
With just over two minutes remaining, Manning led the Colts on a decisive drive. Joseph Addai capped it off with a 3-yard touchdown run, giving the Colts their first lead of the game at 38-34. The Patriots had one final chance, but Brady’s pass was intercepted by Marlin Jackson, sealing the Colts’ victory.
Key Performances
Peyton Manning: Manning’s leadership and precision under pressure were crucial to the Colts’ comeback. He finished with 349 passing yards and one touchdown, overcoming a rough start to lead his team to victory.
Tom Brady: Brady, known for his clutch performances, threw for 232 yards and one touchdown. Despite the loss, his efforts kept the Patriots in contention until the very end.
Joseph Addai: Addai had a standout game, rushing for 56 yards and the game-winning touchdown, providing balance to the Colts’ offense.
Post-Game Impact and Legacy
The Colts’ victory over the Patriots had several significant impacts:
Historic Comeback: The Colts’ 18-point comeback is one of the largest in conference championship history, showcasing their resilience and determination.
Peyton Manning’s Legacy: Manning’s ability to lead his team from behind solidified his reputation as one of the NFL’s greatest quarterbacks.
Colts’ Super Bowl Run: The victory propelled the Colts to Super Bowl XLI, where they defeated the Chicago Bears, earning their first Super Bowl title since relocating to Indianapolis.
Rivalry Impact: The game added another chapter to the storied rivalry between Manning and Brady, two of the greatest quarterbacks of all time.
Why It’s a Top 25 Game
Dramatic Comeback: The Colts’ rally from an 18-point deficit to win the game is one of the most dramatic comebacks in NFL playoff history.
Legendary Performances: Key players like Manning, Brady, and Addai delivered clutch performances, showcasing their skill and determination.
Historic Significance: The game secured the Colts’ first Super Bowl appearance under Manning and cemented his legacy as one of the greatest quarterbacks.
Emotional Rollercoaster: The game’s multiple lead changes and intense moments created an emotional rollercoaster for fans and players alike.
Cultural Legacy: The game’s iconic moments and dramatic finish ensure its place in NFL history and continue to be celebrated by fans.
Conclusion
The 2006 AFC Championship Game between the Indianapolis Colts and the New England Patriots is a testament to the thrilling and unpredictable nature of football. From the Patriots’ early dominance to the Colts’ miraculous comeback and the unforgettable finish, this game had everything that makes football great. The dramatic ending, historic plays, and lasting impact ensure that it will be remembered and celebrated for generations to come.
Whether you’re a Colts fan, a Patriots fan, or simply a lover of the game, the 2006 AFC Championship Game is a shining example of why we love football. It’s a game that will forever be etched in the annals of NFL history, reminding us why we watch, cheer, and fall in love with football. (Anyone else notice that the conclusion for each of these is pretty much identical? Yeah, maybe I’ll have ChatGPT work on that…)
Maybe it’s just my general disdain for the two teams involved–but this starts to feel like the recency bias in generative AI coming through…was it an entertaining game? Sure. Was it really top 25 worthy? Certainly not over some others that are lower on the list, other than it being a conference championship game…
No, the game happened long after the book was published.
The 2014 NFC Championship Game: A Legendary Battle
The 2014 NFC Championship Game between the Seattle Seahawks and the Green Bay Packers is celebrated as one of the greatest games in NFL history. Played on January 18, 2015, at CenturyLink Field in Seattle, this game featured a dramatic comeback, improbable plays, and a thrilling overtime finish. The Seahawks’ incredible rally from a 16-0 halftime deficit to a 28-22 overtime victory over the Packers secured this game’s place in NFL lore and makes it a top 25 NFL game of all time.
Pre-Game Context
The Seattle Seahawks entered the 2014 NFC Championship Game as the defending Super Bowl champions, having finished the regular season with a 12-4 record. Led by head coach Pete Carroll, quarterback Russell Wilson, and a dominant defense known as the “Legion of Boom,” the Seahawks were aiming for a second consecutive Super Bowl appearance.
The Green Bay Packers, under head coach Mike McCarthy, also finished the regular season with a 12-4 record. Quarterback Aaron Rodgers, despite playing with a calf injury, led the Packers with his exceptional play. This matchup was highly anticipated, pitting two of the league’s best teams against each other with a trip to the Super Bowl on the line.
The First Half: Packers Dominate Early
The game began with the Packers taking control, capitalizing on mistakes by the Seahawks. Green Bay’s defense intercepted Russell Wilson twice in the first half, and the Packers’ offense converted those turnovers into points. Rodgers connected with wide receiver Randall Cobb for a touchdown, and Mason Crosby added three field goals, giving the Packers a 16-0 lead at halftime.
Seattle’s offense struggled to find any rhythm, and their usually stout defense had difficulty containing Rodgers and the Packers’ attack. The first half ended with the Seahawks facing a significant deficit and their hopes of returning to the Super Bowl in jeopardy.
The Third Quarter: Seahawks Begin to Rally
The Seahawks started to show signs of life in the third quarter. Although their offense continued to struggle, their defense made crucial stops to keep the game within reach. Seattle’s special teams provided a spark when punter Jon Ryan threw a 19-yard touchdown pass to offensive tackle Garry Gilliam on a fake field goal attempt, cutting the Packers’ lead to 16-7.
Despite this momentum shift, the Packers managed to add another field goal early in the fourth quarter, extending their lead to 19-7. With just over five minutes remaining in the game, the Seahawks needed a miracle to keep their championship hopes alive.
The Fourth Quarter: A Miraculous Comeback
What followed in the final minutes of regulation was one of the most remarkable comebacks in NFL history:
Russell Wilson’s Resilience: Wilson, who had struggled for most of the game, led a crucial touchdown drive, capped by a 1-yard run by Marshawn Lynch. The Seahawks now trailed 19-14 with just over two minutes remaining.
Onside Kick Miracle: The Seahawks executed a perfect onside kick, recovered by wide receiver Chris Matthews. This improbable recovery gave Seattle another chance to take the lead.
Lynch’s Go-Ahead Touchdown: With 1:25 left on the clock, Lynch broke free for a 24-yard touchdown run, giving the Seahawks their first lead of the game at 20-19. A successful two-point conversion pass from Wilson to tight end Luke Willson extended the lead to 22-19.
With just over a minute remaining, Aaron Rodgers led the Packers on a drive that resulted in a game-tying field goal by Mason Crosby, sending the game into overtime at 22-22.
Overtime: Seahawks Seal the Victory
In overtime, the Seahawks won the coin toss and elected to receive. Wilson, showing remarkable composure, orchestrated a game-winning drive. He completed a 35-yard pass to Doug Baldwin, setting up the decisive play. Wilson then connected with Jermaine Kearse for a 35-yard touchdown pass, securing a 28-22 victory for the Seahawks and sending them to Super Bowl XLIX.
Key Performances
Russell Wilson: Despite throwing four interceptions, Wilson displayed incredible resilience, finishing with 209 passing yards and the game-winning touchdown in overtime.
Marshawn Lynch: Lynch had a standout performance, rushing for 157 yards and a crucial go-ahead touchdown late in the fourth quarter.
Aaron Rodgers: Rodgers, despite playing with a calf injury, threw for 178 yards and a touchdown, keeping the Packers competitive until the very end.
Post-Game Impact and Legacy
The Seahawks’ victory over the Packers had several significant impacts:
Historic Comeback: The Seahawks’ 16-point comeback is one of the largest in NFC Championship history, showcasing their resilience and determination.
Russell Wilson’s Legacy: Wilson’s ability to bounce back from adversity and lead his team to victory solidified his reputation as one of the NFL’s top quarterbacks.
Packers’ Heartbreak: The game was a devastating loss for the Packers and their fans, marking one of the most painful moments in Green Bay’s storied history.
NFL Lore: The game is frequently cited as one of the greatest in NFL history, highlighting the drama and excitement of playoff football.
Cultural Impact: The game and its iconic moments, such as the onside kick recovery and the overtime touchdown, are often referenced in sports discussions and highlight reels.
Why It’s a Top 25 Game
Dramatic Comeback: The Seahawks’ rally from a 16-0 halftime deficit to win in overtime is one of the most dramatic comebacks in NFL history.
Historic Plays: Key moments like the fake field goal touchdown, the onside kick recovery, and the game-winning touchdown pass are etched in NFL lore.
Emotional Rollercoaster: The game’s multiple lead changes and intense moments kept fans on the edge of their seats, creating an emotional rollercoaster.
Clutch Performances: Both teams displayed incredible skill and resilience, with standout performances from key players.
Cultural Legacy: The game’s iconic moments and dramatic finish ensure its place in NFL history and continue to be celebrated by fans.
Conclusion
The 2014 NFC Championship Game between the Seattle Seahawks and the Green Bay Packers is a testament to the thrilling and unpredictable nature of football. From the Packers’ early dominance to the Seahawks’ miraculous comeback and the unforgettable overtime finish, this game had everything that makes football great. The dramatic ending, historic plays, and lasting impact ensure that it will be remembered and celebrated for generations to come.
Whether you’re a Seahawks fan, a Packers fan, or simply a lover of the game, the 2014 NFC Championship Game is a shining example of why we love football. It’s a game that will forever be etched in the annals of NFL history, reminding us why we watch, cheer, and fall in love with football.
Another game that I have a vague recollection of watching, although I wasn’t even 10 years old at the time…it’s very possible I didn’t watch it all, but have seen & heard the highlights so many times over the years that I feel like I did…I’m actually a bit surprised this game isn’t higher on this list, given how often it’s talked about. One can only imagine how different the game might be viewed if the Broncos hadn’t laid an egg against the Giants in the Super Bowl–the closest matchup of John Elway‘s first three Super Bowl appearances…
Yes, it was the last game featured in the book, under the ‘Fantastic Finishes’ section.
The Drive: The 1986 AFC Championship Game
The 1986 AFC Championship Game between the Denver Broncos and the Cleveland Browns, famously known as “The Drive,” is celebrated as one of the greatest games in NFL history. Played on January 11, 1987, at Cleveland Municipal Stadium, this game is remembered for its dramatic ending, historic significance, and the legendary performance by Denver quarterback John Elway. The Broncos’ 98-yard drive to tie the game and subsequent victory in overtime secured this game’s place in NFL lore and makes it a top 25 NFL game of all time.
Pre-Game Context
The Denver Broncos, under head coach Dan Reeves, finished the regular season with an 11-5 record, led by their star quarterback John Elway. The Cleveland Browns, coached by Marty Schottenheimer, also had an impressive 12-4 record and were led by quarterback Bernie Kosar. Both teams had strong seasons and were vying for a chance to advance to Super Bowl XXI.
The Browns had the home-field advantage and a fervent fan base, creating an electric atmosphere at Cleveland Municipal Stadium. This game was expected to be a tightly contested battle between two talented teams.
The First Half: A Defensive Struggle
The first half of the game was characterized by strong defensive performances from both teams. The Browns struck first with a touchdown pass from Kosar to Herman Fontenot, giving them a 7-0 lead. The Broncos responded with a field goal by Rich Karlis, making the score 7-3.
Both defenses played exceptionally well, preventing either team from gaining significant momentum. The first half ended with the Browns leading 10-9, as the Broncos managed to add two more field goals.
The Second Half: A Shifting Tide
The third quarter saw both offenses starting to find their rhythm. The Broncos took the lead with a touchdown pass from Elway to Steve Watson, making it 16-10. However, the Browns quickly responded with a touchdown run by Kevin Mack, reclaiming the lead at 17-16.
As the fourth quarter began, the intensity of the game increased. The Browns extended their lead to 20-13 with a field goal by Mark Moseley. With just over five minutes left in the game, Kosar connected with Brian Brennan for a 48-yard touchdown, giving the Browns a 20-13 lead.
The Drive: A Legendary Moment
With 5:32 remaining and the Broncos starting from their own 2-yard line, John Elway orchestrated one of the most iconic drives in NFL history. Here’s a play-by-play of “The Drive”:
1st and 10 at Denver 2: Elway completed a pass to Sammy Winder for five yards.
2nd and 5 at Denver 7: Elway scrambled for 11 yards, resulting in a first down.
1st and 10 at Denver 18: Elway completed a pass to Steve Sewell for 22 yards.
1st and 10 at Denver 40: A short pass to Winder gained three yards.
2nd and 7 at Denver 43: Elway connected with Watson for 12 yards.
1st and 10 at Cleveland 45: A pass to Sewell gained 14 yards.
1st and 10 at Cleveland 31: A pass to Winder for nine yards.
2nd and 1 at Cleveland 22: Elway scrambled for four yards.
1st and 10 at Cleveland 18: A pass to Steve Watson was incomplete.
2nd and 10 at Cleveland 18: Elway hit Mark Jackson for a 20-yard touchdown, tying the game at 20-20.
The drive covered 98 yards in 15 plays, taking just 5 minutes and 2 seconds. Elway’s composure and precision under immense pressure exemplified his greatness and earned him the moniker “The Comeback Kid.”
Overtime: Sealing the Victory
In overtime, the Broncos won the coin toss and elected to receive. Elway continued his stellar play, driving the Broncos down the field. Rich Karlis then kicked a 33-yard field goal, securing a 23-20 victory for the Broncos and sending them to Super Bowl XXI.
Key Performances
John Elway: Elway’s leadership and execution during “The Drive” solidified his reputation as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. He finished the game with 244 passing yards and a touchdown.
Bernie Kosar: Kosar had a strong performance, throwing for 356 yards and three touchdowns. Despite the loss, he kept the Browns competitive throughout the game.
Denver Defense: The Broncos’ defense made crucial stops, especially in the first half, setting the stage for Elway’s heroics.
Post-Game Impact and Legacy
The Broncos’ victory over the Browns in the 1986 AFC Championship Game had several significant impacts:
Elway’s Legacy: “The Drive” became a defining moment in John Elway’s career, symbolizing his clutch performance and resilience.
Browns’ Heartbreak: The game was a crushing blow to the Browns and their fans, marking one of the most painful moments in Cleveland sports history.
NFL History: The game is frequently cited as one of the greatest in NFL history, showcasing the drama and excitement of playoff football.
Cultural Impact: “The Drive” has become a term synonymous with legendary comebacks and is often referenced in sports discussions and highlights.
Why It’s a Top 25 Game
Dramatic Ending: The 98-yard drive to tie the game and the subsequent overtime victory are among the most dramatic finishes in NFL history.
Historic Significance: “The Drive” is a defining moment in NFL lore, representing the pinnacle of clutch performances.
Emotional Rollercoaster: The game featured multiple lead changes and intense moments, keeping fans on the edge of their seats.
Clutch Performances: John Elway’s legendary drive under immense pressure showcased his greatness and solidified his legacy.
Cultural Legacy: The game and “The Drive” are frequently replayed and discussed, securing their place in NFL history.
Conclusion
The 1986 AFC Championship Game between the Denver Broncos and the Cleveland Browns is a testament to the thrilling and unpredictable nature of football. From the defensive struggles in the first half to the legendary 98-yard drive by John Elway, this game had everything that makes football great. The dramatic finish, historic performances, and lasting impact ensure that it will be remembered and celebrated for generations to come.
Whether you’re a Broncos fan, a Browns fan, or simply a lover of the game, the 1986 AFC Championship Game is a shining example of why we love football. It’s a game that will forever be etched in the annals of NFL history, reminding us why we watch, cheer, and fall in love with football.
Finally the purple make the list…and on the right side of history, as well. This game…did not do wonders for my long term health, I’m sure–I actually listened to most of the second half in a blizzard on my way to a Minnesota Wild game…and then watched the tail end walking back and forth from a suite (corporate event) to the hallway above where a few thousand other Wild fans crammed into the concourse to watch on giant screens…and back in to watch the game. A friend of mine at the event (that isn’t really a sports fan) actually filmed the singing of the national anthems (Wild were playing the Canadiens), and this was the result (I uploaded it with his permission):
No, obviously, since it happened long after the book was published–but it almost certainly would be, if the book were re-written today.
The Minneapolis Miracle: A Legendary NFL Game
The 2017 NFC Divisional Playoff game between the Minnesota Vikings and the New Orleans Saints, played on January 14, 2018, is famously known as “The Minneapolis Miracle.” This game is etched in NFL history for its dramatic ending, historic plays, and emotional highs and lows, making it one of the greatest games of all time. The Vikings’ last-second victory, sealed by an improbable touchdown pass, has secured this game’s place in the annals of NFL lore.
Pre-Game Context
The Minnesota Vikings, led by head coach Mike Zimmer, entered the 2017 playoffs with a 13-3 record, boasting the NFL’s top-ranked defense and a solid offense spearheaded by quarterback Case Keenum. The Vikings were playing with the goal of becoming the first team to play a Super Bowl in their home stadium, U.S. Bank Stadium, in Minneapolis.
The New Orleans Saints, under head coach Sean Payton and quarterback Drew Brees, also had a strong season with an 11-5 record. The Saints featured a high-powered offense and a rejuvenated defense. This matchup promised to be a classic battle between two evenly matched teams.
The First Half: Vikings Dominate Early
The Vikings took control early in the game, capitalizing on their home-field advantage and the support of a raucous crowd. Minnesota’s defense stifled the Saints’ potent offense, forcing several punts and turnovers. On offense, Keenum connected with wide receiver Stefon Diggs for a crucial touchdown, and running back Latavius Murray added another score. By halftime, the Vikings had built a commanding 17-0 lead.
The Second Half: Saints’ Comeback
The second half saw a dramatic shift in momentum. Drew Brees, known for his ability to perform under pressure, orchestrated a comeback for the Saints. He threw two touchdown passes to Michael Thomas, and the Saints’ defense tightened up, limiting the Vikings’ offensive production.
As the fourth quarter began, the Vikings’ lead had shrunk to 17-14. Keenum then led a drive that resulted in a field goal, extending the lead to 20-14. However, Brees answered back with a touchdown pass to Alvin Kamara, giving the Saints a 21-20 lead, their first of the game.
With just over three minutes remaining, Keenum led the Vikings downfield, setting up a field goal by kicker Kai Forbath, putting the Vikings back on top, 23-21. Brees, in typical fashion, led the Saints to another field goal, giving the Saints a 24-23 lead with just 25 seconds left on the clock.
The Minneapolis Miracle: A Historic Finish
What happened next is one of the most iconic moments in NFL history. With only 10 seconds remaining and the Vikings on their own 39-yard line, Keenum threw a desperation pass down the right sideline to Stefon Diggs. The Saints’ safety, Marcus Williams, missed the tackle, allowing Diggs to turn and sprint untouched into the end zone for a 61-yard touchdown as time expired.
The play was a stunning end to an already thrilling game, instantly dubbed “The Minneapolis Miracle.” The Vikings’ 29-24 victory sent shockwaves through the football world and left fans in awe of the dramatic finish.
Key Performances
Case Keenum: Keenum finished with 318 passing yards and one touchdown, delivering under pressure when it mattered most. His connection with Diggs for the game-winning play cemented his place in Vikings history.
Stefon Diggs: Diggs caught six passes for 137 yards and one touchdown, with the 61-yard game-winner being the most memorable catch of his career.
Drew Brees: Brees showcased his elite skills, throwing for 294 yards and three touchdowns, leading the Saints’ comeback efforts.
Post-Game Impact and Legacy
The Vikings’ victory over the Saints had several significant impacts:
Historic Play: The “Minneapolis Miracle” is one of the most replayed and talked-about plays in NFL history, symbolizing the unpredictable and thrilling nature of the sport.
Vikings’ Momentum: The victory propelled the Vikings to the NFC Championship Game, although they ultimately fell to the Philadelphia Eagles.
Emotional Highs and Lows: The dramatic swings in the game, from the Saints’ comeback to the Vikings’ last-second win, created an emotional rollercoaster for fans and players alike.
NFL Lore: This game is frequently referenced in discussions of great NFL moments, highlighting the importance of never giving up and playing until the final whistle.
Why It’s a Top 25 Game
Dramatic Ending: The last-second touchdown pass from Keenum to Diggs is one of the most dramatic and unexpected finishes in NFL history.
Historic Significance: The play became known as “The Minneapolis Miracle,” a testament to its impact and the lasting memory it created for fans and players.
Emotional Rollercoaster: The game featured multiple lead changes in the final minutes, keeping fans on the edge of their seats.
Clutch Performances: Both teams displayed incredible skill and resilience, with standout performances from key players.
Cultural Impact: The game and its iconic finish are frequently replayed and discussed, securing its place in NFL history.
Conclusion
The 2017 NFC Divisional Playoff game between the Minnesota Vikings and the New Orleans Saints is a shining example of the excitement and unpredictability that makes football such a beloved sport. From the Vikings’ early dominance to the Saints’ valiant comeback and the unforgettable “Minneapolis Miracle,” this game had everything a football fan could hope for. Its dramatic finish, historic plays, and lasting impact ensure that it will be remembered and celebrated for generations to come.
Whether you’re a Vikings fan, a Saints fan, or simply a lover of the game, the 2017 NFC Divisional Playoff is a testament to the magic that can happen on the football field. It’s a game that will forever be etched in the annals of NFL history, reminding us why we watch, cheer, and fall in love with football.
OK, moving on from the highly debatable #23 Greatest NFL Game, we finally have a game that I clearly remember watching–by 1992, I was in middle school, finally playing tackle football in my small hometown, and for some reason, the Bills were my second favorite team–had a lot to do with the red helmets (especially back when they had the blue facemasks), and for some reason Cornelius Bennett (who’s autographed picture is the only one on my wall that isn’t a Minnesota Viking). If my memory serves me right, by halftime I HAD mostly lost interest in the game–but I left it on, and ended watching a game that I honestly am surprised isn’t higher on this list.
Yes, most definitely–the top game listed in the Comebacks section (not surprisingly), and given that it’s the most recent game in the original book that started this idea (published in 1997), I wouldn’t be surprised if this game served as somewhat of the inspiration for the book in the first place.
The Greatest Comeback in NFL History: Buffalo Bills vs. Houston Oilers, 1992 AFC Wild Card Game
The 1992 AFC Wild Card game between the Buffalo Bills and the Houston Oilers, played on January 3, 1993, is famously known as “The Comeback.” This game is celebrated as one of the greatest in NFL history due to its unprecedented comeback, dramatic moments, and significant impact on the league. The Bills’ miraculous rally from a 32-point deficit to win the game in overtime solidified its place among the top 25 NFL games of all time.
Pre-Game Context
The Buffalo Bills, coached by Marv Levy, were no strangers to the playoffs, having appeared in two consecutive Super Bowls prior to the 1992 season. However, they entered this Wild Card game without their star quarterback, Jim Kelly, who was sidelined with a knee injury. Backup quarterback Frank Reich, known for engineering a remarkable comeback at the University of Maryland, was thrust into the starting role. The Houston Oilers, led by head coach Jack Pardee and quarterback Warren Moon, were a formidable team with a high-powered offense that featured the “Run and Shoot” scheme. The Oilers finished the regular season with a 10-6 record and were looking to advance deep into the playoffs.
The First Half: Oilers Dominate
The game started disastrously for the Bills, as the Oilers quickly established dominance. Warren Moon was nearly flawless, completing 19 of 22 passes for 218 yards and four touchdowns in the first half alone. The Oilers’ aggressive offense and stout defense stifled the Bills, resulting in a 28-3 halftime lead. Adding to the Bills’ woes, early in the third quarter, Moon connected with Webster Slaughter for a 17-yard touchdown, extending the Oilers’ lead to 35-3. At this point, the game seemed all but over, with many fans leaving Rich Stadium in disbelief.
The Second Half: The Comeback Begins
The second half is where the legend of “The Comeback” was born. Frank Reich and the Bills offense finally began to find their rhythm. The rally started with a 1-yard touchdown run by Kenneth Davis, followed by an onside kick recovery that gave the Bills new life. Reich then connected with wide receiver Don Beebe for a 38-yard touchdown, narrowing the deficit to 35-17.
The momentum continued to shift in favor of the Bills. Reich threw a 26-yard touchdown pass to Andre Reed, and the Bills defense, led by linebacker Darryl Talley, forced a crucial turnover. Reich capitalized on the opportunity, finding Reed again for a 14-yard touchdown. Suddenly, the score was 35-31, and the Bills were back in the game.
The Fourth Quarter: Completing the Comeback
The fourth quarter was a rollercoaster of emotions for both teams. The Bills’ defense came up big once more, intercepting Warren Moon, and Reich wasted no time, connecting with Andre Reed for a third touchdown, giving the Bills their first lead of the game at 38-35. The Oilers managed to regroup and tie the game at 38-38 with a field goal, sending the game into overtime.
Overtime: A Historic Finish
In overtime, the Bills’ defense made the critical play of the game. Nate Odomes intercepted a pass from Moon, returning it deep into Oilers’ territory. A few plays later, kicker Steve Christie nailed a 32-yard field goal, sealing a 41-38 victory for the Bills. The comeback was complete, and the stadium erupted in celebration.
Key Performances
Frank Reich: Reich’s performance was nothing short of heroic. He finished with 289 passing yards and four touchdowns, leading the Bills to the largest comeback in NFL history.
Andre Reed: Reed was instrumental in the comeback, catching eight passes for 136 yards and three touchdowns, including the go-ahead score in the fourth quarter.
Warren Moon: Despite the loss, Moon had a remarkable game, throwing for 371 yards and four touchdowns. His performance in the first half was nearly perfect.
Post-Game Impact and Legacy
The Bills’ victory over the Oilers had several significant impacts:
NFL History: The game set the record for the largest comeback in NFL history, a record that stood for nearly 30 years, until the Vikings comeback win over the Colts in the regular season of 2022. It showcased the unpredictability and excitement of playoff football.
Frank Reich’s Legacy: Reich’s leadership and poise under pressure earned him a place in NFL lore. His comeback heroics are often cited as an example of resilience and determination.
Buffalo’s Super Bowl Run: The victory propelled the Bills to their third consecutive Super Bowl appearance, though they ultimately fell short against the Dallas Cowboys.
Cultural Impact: The game is frequently referenced in popular culture and sports discussions, symbolizing the never-give-up attitude and the possibility of miracles in sports.
Why It’s a Top 25 Game
Unprecedented Comeback: The 32-point comeback remains the largest in NFL playoffs history, demonstrating the dramatic potential of the game.
Clutch Performances: Frank Reich’s leadership and Andre Reed’s clutch catches were key to the Bills’ victory.
Historic Significance: The game is etched in NFL history and continues to be a benchmark for great comebacks.
Emotional Rollercoaster: The dramatic swings in momentum and the ultimate triumph made it an emotional rollercoaster for fans and players alike.
Cultural Legacy: “The Comeback” is a term synonymous with resilience and hope in the face of overwhelming odds, resonating beyond the realm of sports.
Conclusion
The 1992 AFC Wild Card game between the Buffalo Bills and the Houston Oilers is a testament to the unpredictable and thrilling nature of football. From the depths of a 32-point deficit to an overtime victory, this game encapsulates the essence of what makes the NFL so captivating. The dramatic comeback, historic performances, and lasting impact on the sport and its culture ensure that this game will be remembered and celebrated for generations to come. Whether you’re a Bills fan, an Oilers fan, or simply a lover of the game, “The Comeback” is a shining example of why we love football.
At #23 on our list of Greatest NFL Games, and as the first Super Bowl, we have the 1987 Super Bowl (played in 1988) between the Denver Broncos and the Washington Redskins. The game was…not close–in fact, at the time it happened, it was just behind the Bears Super Bowl XX drubbing of the Patriots in terms of Super Bowl blowouts. It is notable, though, for the record breaking performance of the Redskins’ offense, and in particular Doug Williams, who was the first ever African-American to start a Super Bowl at quarterback (and to win the game…and to be named MVP).
This is the first game in our list that happened before the book was published–but it’s not in the book as one of their greatest games, likely due to the blowout nature of the game, combined with the fact that the book likely wasn’t looking at games from a social impact perspective.
Super Bowl XXII
Held on January 31, 1988, at Jack Murphy Stadium in San Diego, California, is celebrated (at least by ChatGPT) as one of the most memorable and remarkable games in NFL history. This game featured the Washington Redskins defeating the Denver Broncos with a staggering score of 42-10. The significance of this game lies not only in the overwhelming victory but also in the numerous records set, the historic performances, and the dramatic turn of events that unfolded during the game.
Pre-Game Context
The Denver Broncos, led by quarterback John Elway, entered Super Bowl XXII with high hopes. Elway, known for his strong arm and playmaking ability, had guided the Broncos to a 10-4-1 record during the regular season and a dominant run in the playoffs. The Redskins, under head coach Joe Gibbs, were also a formidable team, having posted an 11-4 record and showcasing a balanced attack on both offense and defense.
The First Quarter: Broncos Strike First
The game began with a bang as the Broncos quickly took the lead. On the very first play from scrimmage, John Elway connected with wide receiver Ricky Nattiel for a 56-yard touchdown pass, putting Denver ahead 7-0. The Broncos then added a field goal, extending their lead to 10-0. At this point, it seemed like the Broncos were on their way to a commanding victory.
The Second Quarter: Redskins’ Unprecedented Explosion
What followed in the second quarter was nothing short of historic. The Washington Redskins orchestrated one of the greatest comebacks in Super Bowl history, scoring 35 unanswered points. This incredible outburst remains the most points scored by a team in a single quarter in Super Bowl history.
Doug Williams’ Heroics: Quarterback Doug Williams, who became the first African American quarterback to start and win a Super Bowl, delivered an unforgettable performance. Despite suffering a knee injury early in the game, Williams returned to the field and threw four touchdown passes in the second quarter alone.
Ricky Sanders‘ Record Day: Wide receiver Ricky Sanders was the primary beneficiary of Williams’ precise passes, catching two touchdown passes and amassing a Super Bowl-record 193 receiving yards.
Timmy Smith‘s Ground Attack: Rookie running back Timmy Smith also made history by rushing for a Super Bowl-record 204 yards and scoring two touchdowns. His unexpected breakout performance remains one of the most remarkable in Super Bowl lore.
The Third and Fourth Quarters: Redskins Dominate
With a 35-10 lead at halftime, the Redskins continued to control the game in the second half. They added another touchdown in the third quarter, extending their lead to 42-10. The Broncos, unable to recover from the second-quarter onslaught, were held scoreless in the second half.
The Redskins’ defense also played a crucial role, shutting down the Broncos’ offense and preventing any further scoring. The Broncos’ vaunted passing attack was neutralized, and John Elway was sacked five times, forcing him into multiple turnovers.
Post-Game Analysis and Legacy
The final score of 42-10 highlighted the Redskins’ dominance and underscored the magnitude of their achievement. Doug Williams was named Super Bowl MVP, finishing the game with 340 passing yards and four touchdown passes. His performance shattered stereotypes and paved the way for future African American quarterbacks in the NFL.
Several factors contribute to Super Bowl XXII’s inclusion in the list of top 25 NFL games of all time:
Historic Quarterback Performance: Doug Williams’ second-quarter performance was a masterclass in quarterback play, and his story of overcoming adversity added a layer of inspiration and significance to the game.
Unprecedented Scoring: The Redskins’ 35-point second quarter remains an unmatched feat in Super Bowl history. The rapid succession of touchdowns showcased the explosive potential of the Redskins’ offense.
Record-Breaking Plays: The game set multiple Super Bowl records, including Timmy Smith’s rushing yards and Ricky Sanders’ receiving yards. These records still stand, emphasizing the extraordinary nature of the Redskins’ performance.
Cultural Impact: Doug Williams’ victory had a profound impact on the NFL and sports culture, breaking barriers and challenging preconceived notions about African American quarterbacks.
Conclusion
Super Bowl XXII is more than just a game; it is a historic moment in NFL history that exemplifies the unpredictable and exhilarating nature of football. The Washington Redskins’ remarkable comeback, record-breaking performances, and Doug Williams’ trailblazing achievement combine to make this game one of the greatest in the annals of the sport. For fans and historians alike, Super Bowl XXII stands as a testament to the drama, excitement, and transformative power of football.
This game will forever be remembered not only for the lopsided score but also for the way it was achieved, demonstrating that in football, anything can happen, and history can be made in the blink of an eye. Whether you’re a Redskins fan, a Broncos fan, or simply a lover of the game, Super Bowl XXII is a reminder of the magic that can unfold on the gridiron.
Loading ...
and history has shown us (eg Albert Lewis) getting moved as semi-finalist into finalist stage last year on modern ballot…
I worry less about 4 moderns per year as with 20 years of eligibility still plenty of time for deserving…
Yea I remain hopeful that the system self corrects or Hall steps in to revise rules so at least we…
Agree with Paul. We have likely entered a “small hall” period (like the 80s and 90s). The backlog of seniors…
If he was truly committed to seeing deserving seniors elected, he first would have completed the final year (class of…