Obviously we’re several days behind on this, and the conversation has already started, but posting for posterity sake–last weekend the Pro Football Hall of Fame did announce their list of 15 modern-era finalists for the Class of 2025. Featured in the group are an interesting a mix of first-time nominees and returning candidates–with Rodney Harrison being a notable exclusion, after advancing to the final 15 last year for the first time.
The selection committee will convene before Super Bowl LIX to elect between three and five inductees from this group.
First-Year Eligible Finalists:
QB Eli Manning: A two-time Super Bowl MVP with the New York Giants, Manning ranks among the top 10 in NFL history for passing yards and touchdowns.
LB Luke Kuechly: A seven-time Pro Bowler and 2013 Defensive Player of the Year, Kuechly was renowned for his leadership with the Carolina Panthers.
LB/DE Terrell Suggs: Accumulating 139 sacks over his career, Suggs earned the 2011 Defensive Player of the Year award and was a pivotal part of the Baltimore Ravens’ defense.
K Adam Vinatieri: The NFL’s all-time leading scorer with 2,673 points, Vinatieri’s clutch kicking secured multiple Super Bowl victories for the New England Patriots.
G Marshal Yanda: An eight-time Pro Bowler with the Baltimore Ravens, Yanda was a cornerstone of their offensive line.
Returning Finalists:
TE Antonio Gates: Holding the record for most touchdown receptions by a tight end (116), Gates was a key offensive weapon for the San Diego/Los Angeles Chargers.
DE Jared Allen: With 136 career sacks, Allen was a dominant pass rusher for teams including the Kansas City Chiefs and Minnesota Vikings.
WR Torry Holt: A vital part of the St. Louis Rams’ “Greatest Show on Turf,” Holt amassed over 13,000 receiving yards in his career.
WR Reggie Wayne: Ranking 10th all-time in receiving yards, Wayne was a consistent target for the Indianapolis Colts.
WR Steve Smith: A five-time Pro Bowler & two-time All-Pro who totaled 14,731 receiving yards and totaled 87 touchdowns in his career.
T Willie Anderson: A three-time Pro Bowler with the Cincinnati Bengals, Anderson was known for his pass protection skills.
G Jahri Evans: A six-time Pro Bowler with the New Orleans Saints, Evans was instrumental in their offensive success.
S Darren Woodson: A three-time Super Bowl champion with the Dallas Cowboys, Woodson was a defensive leader throughout his career.
DB Eric Allen: With 54 career interceptions, Allen was a standout for the Philadelphia Eagles and other teams.
RB Fred Taylor: Rushing for over 11,000 yards, Taylor was a key offensive player for the Jacksonville Jaguars.
The final selections for the Hall of Fame will be announced during the “NFL Honors” show on February 6, 2025, in New Orleans, with enshrinement ceremonies scheduled for August in Canton, Ohio.
The Pro Football Hall of Fame unveiled their list of 25 modern era players that are finalists to be inducted into the class of 2025 this morning. On the list include:
Seven first time finalists made the cut, and Torry Holt is the most “veteran” of the group at 11 times as a semifinalist, a player that almost everyone seems to acknowledge belongs in the Hall, but continues to get caught up in a WR logjam.
Recently in the 2025 Hall of Fame post (and I think in the 2024 post before that) it was mentioned in the comments that we won’t see another first ballot Hall of Famer until Drew Brees & Larry Fitzgerald in 2026. Didn’t think much of it at first, but after thinking about it some more, I started to wonder–given the stingy nature of the Hall of Fame voters when it comes to first ballot wide receivers, will Fitzgerald make that cut?
When it comes to the Pro Football Hall of Fame, the term “first-ballot” carries significant weight. It’s reserved for players whose careers were so impactful that their induction feels inevitable from the moment they retire (and in many cases before), not just become eligible. With Fitzgerald, I don’t believe I’ve ever seen anyone doubt his eventual induction–but there have been some that do claim that he didn’t stand out enough to be first ballot (to be fair, most of that came on Reddit, and appears to have started before he retired).
To be fair, this is only really a question due to how many wide receivers have had to (and continue to) wait in line for their enshrinement…so to answer this, we must compare his career to the most recent wide receivers who were enshrined on their first try—Jerry Rice, Randy Moss, and Calvin Johnson—as well as some of those contemporaries who have had to wait, such as Cris Carter, Terrell Owens, Tim Brown, Marvin Harrison, Andre Johnson & Isaac Bruce–as well as a couple that are still waiting.
Larry Fitzgerald: A Case for First-Ballot Induction
First, let’s take a look at Fitzgerald’s career:
Career Stats: 1,432 receptions, 17,492 receiving yards, 121 touchdowns
Postseason Accolades: 1x First-Team All-Pro, 11x Pro Bowler, NFL 100 All-Time Team
Larry Fitzgerald’s numbers speak for themselves–there’s no doubt he is a Hall of Famer, and he will be inducted into Canton–again, the only question here is whether or not he will make it on the first ballot. He ranks second all-time in receptions and receiving yards, trailing only Jerry Rice, and his postseason performance is one of the most clutch in NFL history. His 2008 playoff run, where he set a record with 546 receiving yards and seven touchdowns in four games, almost single-handedly led the Cardinals to their first Super Bowl appearance.
Unlike some of the players who had to wait, Fitzgerald’s character and off-field contributions are exemplary. He’s widely regarded as one of the most respected players in the league, known for his sportsmanship, community service, and leadership.
As we look ahead to the 2025 Pro Football Hall of Fame class, the list of potential inductees includes an interesting mix of first-year eligible players and returning finalists who have come close in previous years. This class is poised to generate significant debate, as due to overall career length (Kuechly), hot and cold regular season performance vs postseason heroics (Manning) and position (Vinatieri), there are arguments for and against basically all the first year candidates. Add in a list of at least six candidates that have made the final five cut list in the last two years, with Jared Allen making it in 2023 but not 2024, and it shapes up to be an interesting class for sure.
2025 First-Year Hall of Fame Eligibles
Luke Kuechly: Kuechly, with his seven Pro Bowl selections, five First-Team All-Pro nods, and 2013 Defensive Player of the Year award, leads this year’s list of first-time eligible players. Though his career was cut short by injury, his impact on the field was undeniable, making him a strong contender for first-ballot induction–and the election of Patrick Willis signifies that career length isn’t as big of a deal as some might think.
Eli Manning: Manning’s Hall of Fame credentials are well-known, with two Super Bowl MVPs and top-10 rankings in passing yards and touchdowns. His postseason heroics, particularly in defeating the Patriots twice, could secure his place in the Hall on his first try.
Marshawn Lynch: Known for his punishing running style and “Beast Mode” persona, Lynch rushed for over 10,000 yards and 85 touchdowns in his career. His memorable playoff performances, including the iconic “Beast Quake” run, make him a compelling candidate.
Earl Thomas: A key member of the Seahawks’ “Legion of Boom,” Thomas was a seven-time Pro Bowler and a three-time First-Team All-Pro. His ball-hawking ability and leadership in the secondary played a critical role in Seattle’s Super Bowl XLVIII victory.
Adam Vinatieri: Vinatieri is arguably the most clutch kicker in NFL history, with four Super Bowl rings and multiple game-winning kicks in the biggest moments. As the NFL’s all-time leading scorer, his induction feels inevitable.
Terrell Suggs: Suggs, a dominant force on the Ravens’ defense, ranks eighth all-time in sacks with 139 and won Defensive Player of the Year in 2011. His physical style and leadership helped Baltimore secure two Super Bowl titles.
Travis Frederick: Frederick was a five-time Pro Bowler and a key piece of the Cowboys’ dominant offensive line. His sudden retirement due to illness cut short a promising career, but his impact during his time in the league was significant.
Darren Sproles: Sproles, one of the most versatile players in NFL history, was a dynamic return specialist, rusher, and receiver. His ability to make plays in multiple phases of the game earned him a spot in the NFL’s All-Decade Team of the 2010s.
Returning Finalists
Torry Holt: Holt, who was one of the final five candidates eliminated in 2024, remains a top contender for induction. As a key member of the “Greatest Show on Turf,” Holt’s career was defined by consistency and excellence, amassing over 13,000 receiving yards and 74 touchdowns.
Reggie Wayne: Like Holt, Wayne was also among the final five eliminated in 2024. His connection with Peyton Manning and his clutch performances in big games make him one of the top wide receivers not yet in the Hall.
Antonio Gates: Gates, the greatest tight end in NFL history in terms of touchdown receptions, was another final 10 finalist in 2024. His athleticism and ability to create mismatches made him a nightmare for defenses and a cornerstone of the Chargers’ offense for years.
Willie Anderson: Anderson, a four-time Pro Bowler and three-time First-Team All-Pro, was also in the final 10 in 2024. As one of the most dominant right tackles of his era, Anderson’s candidacy continues to gain momentum.
Darren Woodson: Woodson, a key member of the Cowboys’ defense during their 1990s dynasty, also made it to the final five eliminated in 2024. His physicality and versatility at safety earned him three Super Bowl rings and five Pro Bowl selections.
Jared Allen: After being in the final 10 in 2023 but not in 2024, Allen remains a strong candidate. With 136 career sacks, Allen was one of the most feared pass rushers of his era, and his consistent production over 12 seasons makes him a likely Hall of Famer.
Jahri Evans: Evans, a six-time Pro Bowler and four-time First-Team All-Pro, was a dominant force on the Saints’ offensive line. His blocking helped New Orleans to multiple playoff appearances, including their Super Bowl XLIV win.
Rodney Harrison: Harrison, a hard-hitting safety known for his physical style, was a key part of the Patriots’ dynasty in the early 2000s. With two Super Bowl rings and four All-Pro selections, his candidacy continues to be debated.
Fred Taylor: Taylor’s career numbers, including nearly 12,000 rushing yards, have kept him in the conversation, though injuries during his career may have impacted his chances. His consistency and explosiveness at running back make him a strong candidate.
Eric Allen: Allen, with 54 career interceptions and six Pro Bowl selections, was one of the best cornerbacks of his era. His leadership in the secondary and ability to make big plays in critical moments keep him in the discussion for induction.
Semifinalists From 2024
The list of semifinalists cut before the final round of voting in 2024 includes several players who may continue to make a push for the Hall in 2025:
With another year of no sure thing first year candidates, and a considerable logjam still existing at WR, the 2025 Pro Football Hall of Fame Class debate will undoubtedly be as interesting as the debate for the 2024 class–and that’s just the modern day candidates, as obviously the senior & contributor candidates are also hotly debated.
Leave your comments below on where you think the class debate will head!
At first I was thinking more recency bias…but as I read the recap, I vaguely remember watching this game, and actually being pretty impressed by it. This was well past the time of Tom Brady ascending from the incredible story of a sixth round pick winning a Super Bowl to an annoying Super Bowl fixture, and around the time that everyone legitimately started to think that Peyton Manning (and Tony Dungy) might never live up to their ultimate expectations–in large part due to Brady. Either way, I was going to cheer for the winner of this one against the overrated Bears–but getting to see Manning finally have a chance at a Super Bowl (before HE ascended to overexposed advertising icon) was definitely a classic…although I’m still not 100% sure it belongs in the top 25.
No, another game that happened long after the book was published.
The 2006 AFC Championship Game: Colts vs. Patriots – A Legendary Clash
The 2006 AFC Championship Game between the Indianapolis Colts and the New England Patriots is remembered as one of the greatest games in NFL history. Played on January 21, 2007, at the RCA Dome in Indianapolis, this game featured a dramatic comeback, legendary performances, and a thrilling finish that secured its place among the top 25 NFL games of all time. The Colts’ remarkable rally from an 18-point deficit to a 38-34 victory over the Patriots showcased the resilience and determination of one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history, Peyton Manning.
Pre-Game Context
The Indianapolis Colts, led by head coach Tony Dungy and quarterback Peyton Manning, finished the regular season with a 12-4 record. The Colts were known for their high-powered offense, featuring wide receivers Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne, and running back Joseph Addai. Despite their regular-season success, the Colts had struggled in previous playoff matchups against their perennial rivals, the New England Patriots.
The Patriots, under head coach Bill Belichick and quarterback Tom Brady, were seeking their fourth Super Bowl appearance in six years. With a 12-4 regular-season record, the Patriots were known for their disciplined defense, clutch performances, and the leadership of Brady. This matchup was highly anticipated, pitting two of the league’s best quarterbacks against each other with a trip to Super Bowl XLI on the line.
The First Half: Patriots Dominate Early
The game began with the Patriots taking control early, capitalizing on Colts’ mistakes and showcasing their defensive prowess. New England’s Asante Samuel intercepted a pass from Manning and returned it 39 yards for a touchdown, giving the Patriots a 21-3 lead. The Colts managed to score a field goal, but the Patriots responded with another touchdown, extending their lead to 21-6 at halftime.
Indianapolis’ offense struggled to find rhythm, and their usually stout defense had difficulty containing Brady and the Patriots’ attack. The first half ended with the Colts facing an 18-point deficit, and their Super Bowl dreams appeared to be slipping away.
The Second Half: Colts Begin to Rally
The second half saw a dramatic shift in momentum. The Colts came out with renewed energy and determination. Manning led a touchdown drive, capped by a 1-yard run by Dan Klecko, and followed by a successful two-point conversion pass to Marvin Harrison, cutting the Patriots’ lead to 21-14.
The Colts’ defense then made a crucial stop, and Manning orchestrated another scoring drive, culminating in a 1-yard touchdown run by center Jeff Saturday, who recovered a fumble in the end zone. The game was now tied at 21-21, and the RCA Dome was electrified with the possibility of an epic comeback.
The Fourth Quarter: A Battle to the Finish
The fourth quarter was a back-and-forth battle, with both teams trading scores in a dramatic showdown:
Patriots Strike Back: Brady connected with Jabar Gaffney for a 6-yard touchdown pass, giving the Patriots a 28-21 lead.
Colts Respond: Manning led another drive, resulting in a 12-yard touchdown pass to Reggie Wayne. However, the extra point was blocked, leaving the Colts trailing 28-27.
Patriots Extend the Lead: The Patriots added two field goals, increasing their lead to 34-31.
With just over two minutes remaining, Manning led the Colts on a decisive drive. Joseph Addai capped it off with a 3-yard touchdown run, giving the Colts their first lead of the game at 38-34. The Patriots had one final chance, but Brady’s pass was intercepted by Marlin Jackson, sealing the Colts’ victory.
Key Performances
Peyton Manning: Manning’s leadership and precision under pressure were crucial to the Colts’ comeback. He finished with 349 passing yards and one touchdown, overcoming a rough start to lead his team to victory.
Tom Brady: Brady, known for his clutch performances, threw for 232 yards and one touchdown. Despite the loss, his efforts kept the Patriots in contention until the very end.
Joseph Addai: Addai had a standout game, rushing for 56 yards and the game-winning touchdown, providing balance to the Colts’ offense.
Post-Game Impact and Legacy
The Colts’ victory over the Patriots had several significant impacts:
Historic Comeback: The Colts’ 18-point comeback is one of the largest in conference championship history, showcasing their resilience and determination.
Peyton Manning’s Legacy: Manning’s ability to lead his team from behind solidified his reputation as one of the NFL’s greatest quarterbacks.
Colts’ Super Bowl Run: The victory propelled the Colts to Super Bowl XLI, where they defeated the Chicago Bears, earning their first Super Bowl title since relocating to Indianapolis.
Rivalry Impact: The game added another chapter to the storied rivalry between Manning and Brady, two of the greatest quarterbacks of all time.
Why It’s a Top 25 Game
Dramatic Comeback: The Colts’ rally from an 18-point deficit to win the game is one of the most dramatic comebacks in NFL playoff history.
Legendary Performances: Key players like Manning, Brady, and Addai delivered clutch performances, showcasing their skill and determination.
Historic Significance: The game secured the Colts’ first Super Bowl appearance under Manning and cemented his legacy as one of the greatest quarterbacks.
Emotional Rollercoaster: The game’s multiple lead changes and intense moments created an emotional rollercoaster for fans and players alike.
Cultural Legacy: The game’s iconic moments and dramatic finish ensure its place in NFL history and continue to be celebrated by fans.
Conclusion
The 2006 AFC Championship Game between the Indianapolis Colts and the New England Patriots is a testament to the thrilling and unpredictable nature of football. From the Patriots’ early dominance to the Colts’ miraculous comeback and the unforgettable finish, this game had everything that makes football great. The dramatic ending, historic plays, and lasting impact ensure that it will be remembered and celebrated for generations to come.
Whether you’re a Colts fan, a Patriots fan, or simply a lover of the game, the 2006 AFC Championship Game is a shining example of why we love football. It’s a game that will forever be etched in the annals of NFL history, reminding us why we watch, cheer, and fall in love with football. (Anyone else notice that the conclusion for each of these is pretty much identical? Yeah, maybe I’ll have ChatGPT work on that…)
Loading ...
and history has shown us (eg Albert Lewis) getting moved as semi-finalist into finalist stage last year on modern ballot…
I worry less about 4 moderns per year as with 20 years of eligibility still plenty of time for deserving…
Yea I remain hopeful that the system self corrects or Hall steps in to revise rules so at least we…
Agree with Paul. We have likely entered a “small hall” period (like the 80s and 90s). The backlog of seniors…
If he was truly committed to seeing deserving seniors elected, he first would have completed the final year (class of…