It’s been an amazing postseason with six memorable divisional and championship round games. And now it’s down to this weekend’s clash between the SuperTeam Los Angeles Rams and the Decades-in-the-making Rebuilt Cincinnati Bengals.
After a hugely successful wild card weekend, Andy and Tony came down to Earth a bit during the divisional games last week.
But it was worth it for what might have been the best slate of playoff games in a long time.
Andy
Tony
Straight-up divisional
2-2
1-3
Spread divisional
2-2
1-3
Straight-up playoffs
8-2
6-4
Spread playoffs
7-3
5-5
I’m not sure the conference championship match-ups have the same appeal that the divisional round games have, but the postseason action has been sizzling so far. Maybe these games will surprise us.
Sunday, January 30
Bengals at Chiefs (-7, 54.5)
Andy: It’s interesting that the total has gone from 51 to 54.5. Not sure that’s high enough yet. Kansas City has been on fire offensively of late. And it took every ounce of it to outlast Buffalo. I think the Chiefs-Bills game should have been the conference championship. I’ve enjoyed watching Cincinnati’s run and Joe Burrow is definitely establishing himself as one of the league’s great clutch QBs. As good as that offense is, I’m not sure he can keep pace for an entire game with Pat Mahomes and his arsenal. Yet. Cincinnati is a couple offensive linemen and a couple defensive pieces away from being a really, really big threat. But this weekend, Kansas City pulls away in the end. Chiefs 38-27.
Tony: I’ve heard talk this week of the Bengals “playing with house money” because they didn’t expect their truly competitive window to open until next year. True, they still need help on the offensive line, and a few other spots–but they damn well better be thinking about this opportunity rather than “playing with house money,” because next year’s competitive window can slam shut pretty quickly. That being said, I really don’t think they have what it’s going to take to hold down Patrick Mahomes for a full 60 minutes, thereby subjecting America (and Mahomes) to more of of the ridiculous antics of his wife & brother. Chiefs 42-28.
49ers at Rams (-3.5, 46)
Andy: Well, Matthew Stafford has been getting monkeys off his back all post-season. His dominating first half against Tampa, coupled with the last second drive to stave off the Bucs’ comeback attempt, is just what he was brought in to do. The Cinderella 49ers have been impressive in “upsets” over Dallas and Green Bay, two teams whose playoff performances in recent years have shown that it is hard to get to the Super Bowl with your hands wrapped tightly around your throats. So, who wins this rematch of the 1989 NFC Championship game? The Rams are probably a little better team right now. But San Francisco has won six straight in this series and Kyle Shanahan seems to have a bit of a place in Sean McVay’s head. I’m pulling a little bit for Stafford, who I’ve always thought was pretty good even while he was serving his sentence in Detroit. I think he’s on a mission. I think he snaps the streak and claws his way to a Super Bowl. Rams 30-17.
Tony: Not going to lie, my season largely came to an official end last Saturday, when I knew I didn’t have to worry about obnoxious Packer fans here in Minnesota muddying up my social media streams about the #LastDance BS. In fact, it’s been quite amusing watching many of them this week try to convince themselves that they’re better off without Aaron Rodgers. And other than listening to a bunch of Rodgers jock sniffing pundits on national sports media, it should be another fun offseason of Packer drama too.
Oh, there’s still an NFC Championship game to play? I’ll go 49ers, 20-17, just to be different.
If these two could pick like this all season long, they’d be nationally sought after for their brilliant analysis. Or they’d be regulars in the big shot rooms in Vegas, playing high-stakes blackjack and getting paid to show up at the fancy after-hours venues.
But alas, it’s more likely this is a case of the proverbial “sun shining on a dog’s ass.” So, they’ll enjoy it while they can while most likely crashing down to Earth this weekend.
Andy
Tony
Straight-up wild card
6-0
5-1
Spread wild card
5-1
4-2
Tony might have hit five spreads too, but he inexplicably picked one game to end as a push – a gutty move, but not necessarily a profitable one. But it was still a winning week.
Now, for the greatest week of the football season – the divisional round of the playoffs – here goes.
Saturday, January 22
Bengals at Titans (-3.5, 47.5) –
Andy: I’ve been wrestling with all of these games all week, this one as much as any other. I love the direction Cincinnati is going. They’ve got a great RB who seems to be taking his game to the next level. They’ve got three good-to-great WRs, a couple of whom could be top-level stars. They’ve got a capable TE and they have Joe Burrow, who seems on a trajectory to be one of the league’s best. Then you have Tennessee, which wouldn’t have been my pick to be the top AFC seed even before Derrick Henry got hurt. And when he did, the team just kept finding ways to win. Mike Vrabel has been money after bye weeks. And, while Ryan Tannehill is no Joe Burrow, he’s just generally solid. So, do the upstart Bengals keep rolling? Or do the boring-but-fundamentally-sound Titans bring them down to Earth? All week long I’ve been on Tennessee. But as game time approaches, I’m moving toward Cincinnati exploiting a secondary that can be beaten and keeping up the roll. They’re going to have to score TDs instead of FGs in order to win. I think they will. Bengals 28-20.
Tony: Unfortunately I don’t have a lot of time this week to break down games, between hockey, work, and people whining about my ability to run fantasy football leagues two weeks after the season ends. Don’t even have time to create the custom image for this post. Just to be different, I’ll pick the Titans here–Derrick Henry could easily be the difference, especially well rested. Titans 31-24.
49ers at Packers (-5.5, 47) –
Andy: I really, really want this game to be a repeat of the last couple times San Francisco and Green Bay met in the playoffs, when the 49ers have steamrolled the Pack. And the recipe is there – Green Bay has given up a bottom-five 4.7 yards per carry on the ground and San Francisco has guys who can run the ball. The problem is the Packers are explosive enough on offense to prevent San Francisco from having the opportunity to control the game by running all over them. I’ve been trying to come up with scenarios where I think Green Bay gets upset here. But San Francisco is coming off a short week for its second road playoff game in seven days after an emotional win over Dallas. Teams sometimes come back rusty after bye weeks, but I don’t think it matters here. Packers 30-15.
Tony: I hear a lot of talk of Aaron Rodgers being all good with the Packers now, and likely to return in 2022. All it takes is one choke job, one stupid play call, to bring that crashing back down. Unfortunately I don’t think that happens this week–Packers 34-17.
Sunday, January 23
Rams at Buccaneers (-3, 47.5) —
Andy: Matt Stafford exorcised one demon last week, getting his first postseason win in four tries. L.A. will be on short rest too, having played in the NFL’s blatant money-grab Monday-nighter. Both of these teams continue to miss key pieces. But the Rams got Cam Akers back on Monday, adding another piece to their puzzle. Tampa might get Leonard Fournette and Ronald Jones back. But their losses have been mitigated to a degree by the play of Ke’Shawn Vaughn the last couple weeks. One big loss would be Tristan Wirfs, the all-pro tackle likely to miss a match-up against the Aaron Donald-led defensive line. This should be a fun one. If I was in Vegas I’m not sure I’d bet on the game. Given the lack of stakes here, I think I’m picking the upset. The Rams seem to be getting on a bit of a roll. Rams 34-31.
Tony: A -3 line in the playoffs? An absolute toss up? Yikes. I’m going to go with the GOAT in this one. Buccaneers 27-17.
Bills at Chiefs (-1.5, 54) —
Andy: Aaaaand the Main Event. Buffalo went into Kansas City earlier this year and won. The Chiefs are playing better now than they did then. But there’s just something a little off about Kansas City this season. Even when they’ve looked good, it just hasn’t been as dominant as the last couple years. The concern with Buffalo has been that they were built more like a dome team than an outdoor-in-the-playoffs kind of team, but those concerns were at least partially allayed last week in a dominating win over New England. Josh Allen and Devin Singletary are giving Buffalo some semblance of a rushing attack. If they can get that going against the Chiefs this weekend I think they, too, can pull what would be at this point, just a small upset. Bills 34-31.
Tony: A lot of people are calling this the AFC Championship Game. A lot of people are right. Although I do wonder if whichever team wins will be in for a let down next weekend. Despite a growing annoyance with their fan base, I would like the Bills to win, just to change things up in the AFC side of the Super Bowl. Alas, I am a Vikings fan–I am used to not getting what I want when it comes to football. Chiefs win 27-24.
Mercifully, the season is down to its final week. Andy and Tony have gone back and forth with hot and cold streaks all season and now it will finally be done.
Week 17
Tie 8-8
Season
Tony 128-127-1
So, who takes the prize. Gets the imaginary trophy? We’ll find out here.
1 Tony – Colts over Jaguars – The Colts are technically still playing for that last playoff spot–a win here locks it up. A loss here is both embarrassing and opens the door to others jumping in front of them. The Colts will take care of business. (more…)
Andy worked really hard to climb out of a deep early hole to eventually claim the lead in Alternative Picks 2021. Then, in a week, he gave it right back.
Tony’s dominant performance in the first week sans byes for a while reclaimed the top spot by the slimmest of margins heading into the season’s last three weeks.
Week 15
Tony 11-5
Season
Tony 112-111-1
The lights were on late in Andy’s office this week as he … desperately tried to make sure all the necessary Christmas presents were purchased. What, did you think I was going to say he was poring over stats? Crunching numbers? Isn’t it clear at this point that both of these guys have been throwing darts all season.
Here are the picks.
1) Andy – Eagles over Giants – Can’t say I blame Tony for going 2 and 3 in this one. Lots of lopsided games, though at least a couple tricky ones. I don’t like putting NFC East games this high. They go haywire at times. But the Eagles have found their identity, while the Giants might be working with their third-string QB. On paper this one should be over early.
Yes on offense I agree that controlling the ball via rushing attack is needed but like the Lions found out…
Paul: easier said than done. Daniels is not your typical rookie qb. He already has more no punt/no turnover games…
Key will be for Eagles defense to press Daniels (as rookie QB) into mistakes and perhaps INT-take advantage of his…
Brian Wolf: I love your optimism, but I’m not so sure. Philly is a deeply flawed team, but I’m not…
Good playoff games this weekend, with the Bills getting another chance to beat the Chiefs in postseason. I predict they…