**UPDATED**

OK, moving on from the highly debatable #23 Greatest NFL Game, we finally have a game that I clearly remember watching–by 1992, I was in middle school, finally playing tackle football in my small hometown, and for some reason, the Bills were my second favorite team–had a lot to do with the red helmets (especially back when they had the blue facemasks), and for some reason Cornelius Bennett (who’s autographed picture is the only one on my wall that isn’t a Minnesota Viking). If my memory serves me right, by halftime I HAD mostly lost interest in the game–but I left it on, and ended watching a game that I honestly am surprised isn’t higher on this list.

Was This Game in the Original List From The Book?

Yes, most definitely–the top game listed in the Comebacks section (not surprisingly), and given that it’s the most recent game in the original book that started this idea (published in 1997), I wouldn’t be surprised if this game served as somewhat of the inspiration for the book in the first place.

The Greatest Comeback in NFL History: Buffalo Bills vs. Houston Oilers, 1992 AFC Wild Card Game

The 1992 AFC Wild Card game between the Buffalo Bills and the Houston Oilers, played on January 3, 1993, is famously known as “The Comeback.” This game is celebrated as one of the greatest in NFL history due to its unprecedented comeback, dramatic moments, and significant impact on the league. The Bills’ miraculous rally from a 32-point deficit to win the game in overtime solidified its place among the top 25 NFL games of all time.

Pre-Game Context

The Buffalo Bills, coached by Marv Levy, were no strangers to the playoffs, having appeared in two consecutive Super Bowls prior to the 1992 season. However, they entered this Wild Card game without their star quarterback, Jim Kelly, who was sidelined with a knee injury. Backup quarterback Frank Reich, known for engineering a remarkable comeback at the University of Maryland, was thrust into the starting role. The Houston Oilers, led by head coach Jack Pardee and quarterback Warren Moon, were a formidable team with a high-powered offense that featured the “Run and Shoot” scheme. The Oilers finished the regular season with a 10-6 record and were looking to advance deep into the playoffs.

The First Half: Oilers Dominate

The game started disastrously for the Bills, as the Oilers quickly established dominance. Warren Moon was nearly flawless, completing 19 of 22 passes for 218 yards and four touchdowns in the first half alone. The Oilers’ aggressive offense and stout defense stifled the Bills, resulting in a 28-3 halftime lead. Adding to the Bills’ woes, early in the third quarter, Moon connected with Webster Slaughter for a 17-yard touchdown, extending the Oilers’ lead to 35-3. At this point, the game seemed all but over, with many fans leaving Rich Stadium in disbelief.

The Second Half: The Comeback Begins

The second half is where the legend of “The Comeback” was born. Frank Reich and the Bills offense finally began to find their rhythm. The rally started with a 1-yard touchdown run by Kenneth Davis, followed by an onside kick recovery that gave the Bills new life. Reich then connected with wide receiver Don Beebe for a 38-yard touchdown, narrowing the deficit to 35-17.

The momentum continued to shift in favor of the Bills. Reich threw a 26-yard touchdown pass to Andre Reed, and the Bills defense, led by linebacker Darryl Talley, forced a crucial turnover. Reich capitalized on the opportunity, finding Reed again for a 14-yard touchdown. Suddenly, the score was 35-31, and the Bills were back in the game.

The Fourth Quarter: Completing the Comeback

The fourth quarter was a rollercoaster of emotions for both teams. The Bills’ defense came up big once more, intercepting Warren Moon, and Reich wasted no time, connecting with Andre Reed for a third touchdown, giving the Bills their first lead of the game at 38-35. The Oilers managed to regroup and tie the game at 38-38 with a field goal, sending the game into overtime.

Overtime: A Historic Finish

In overtime, the Bills’ defense made the critical play of the game. Nate Odomes intercepted a pass from Moon, returning it deep into Oilers’ territory. A few plays later, kicker Steve Christie nailed a 32-yard field goal, sealing a 41-38 victory for the Bills. The comeback was complete, and the stadium erupted in celebration.

Key Performances

  • Frank Reich: Reich’s performance was nothing short of heroic. He finished with 289 passing yards and four touchdowns, leading the Bills to the largest comeback in NFL history.
  • Andre Reed: Reed was instrumental in the comeback, catching eight passes for 136 yards and three touchdowns, including the go-ahead score in the fourth quarter.
  • Warren Moon: Despite the loss, Moon had a remarkable game, throwing for 371 yards and four touchdowns. His performance in the first half was nearly perfect.

Post-Game Impact and Legacy

The Bills’ victory over the Oilers had several significant impacts:

  • NFL History: The game set the record for the largest comeback in NFL history, a record that stood for nearly 30 years, until the Vikings comeback win over the Colts in the regular season of 2022. It showcased the unpredictability and excitement of playoff football.
  • Frank Reich’s Legacy: Reich’s leadership and poise under pressure earned him a place in NFL lore. His comeback heroics are often cited as an example of resilience and determination.
  • Buffalo’s Super Bowl Run: The victory propelled the Bills to their third consecutive Super Bowl appearance, though they ultimately fell short against the Dallas Cowboys.
  • Cultural Impact: The game is frequently referenced in popular culture and sports discussions, symbolizing the never-give-up attitude and the possibility of miracles in sports.

Why It’s a Top 25 Game

  1. Unprecedented Comeback: The 32-point comeback remains the largest in NFL playoffs history, demonstrating the dramatic potential of the game.
  2. Clutch Performances: Frank Reich’s leadership and Andre Reed’s clutch catches were key to the Bills’ victory.
  3. Historic Significance: The game is etched in NFL history and continues to be a benchmark for great comebacks.
  4. Emotional Rollercoaster: The dramatic swings in momentum and the ultimate triumph made it an emotional rollercoaster for fans and players alike.
  5. Cultural Legacy: “The Comeback” is a term synonymous with resilience and hope in the face of overwhelming odds, resonating beyond the realm of sports.

Conclusion

The 1992 AFC Wild Card game between the Buffalo Bills and the Houston Oilers is a testament to the unpredictable and thrilling nature of football. From the depths of a 32-point deficit to an overtime victory, this game encapsulates the essence of what makes the NFL so captivating. The dramatic comeback, historic performances, and lasting impact on the sport and its culture ensure that this game will be remembered and celebrated for generations to come. Whether you’re a Bills fan, an Oilers fan, or simply a lover of the game, “The Comeback” is a shining example of why we love football.